Fighting Bogus Reports

By YIN PUMIN

Fighting Bogus Reports

By YIN PUMIN

Anti-misinformation groups emerge to patrol the micro-blogosphere

As people across China mourned the tragic loss of life in the high-speed train crash on July 23 near Wenzhou,Zhejiang Province, Internet forums were awash with comments, expressing sadness and anger at the accident. But as millions of messages were posted and reposted,ordinary Internet users began to struggle to discern which pieces of information were accurate and which were misleading.

A netizen self-proclaimed Guo Yao posted a piece of information on Sina Weibo,a twitter-like micro-blog service, on July 29, claiming her 100-day-old baby, Wang Yixuan, died in the accident but was not on the list of victims.

Micro-blog users including Wu Danhong, an associate professor at the China University of Political Science and Law,examined the pictures Guo had posted, and found they weren’t authentic. It has been confirmed the blogger didn’t actually lose her baby in the Wenzhou accident.

In this digital age, misleading information spreads at extraordinary speed over the Internet. Micro-blogging platforms in particular, allow information and disinformation to be disseminated at an unprecedented pace.

“Facing the challenge of disinformation, Internet users, the government and site operators are wondering how to manage the micro-blogosphere,” said Dou Hanzhang, a Beijing-based researcher who helped form an anti-misinformation group on Sina Weibo earlier this year.

A rising power

By June this year, the number of microblog users in China stood at 195 million,accounting for 40 percent of all Internet users in the country.

An annual report on China’s Internet users’ opinions, released by the Communication University of China in March, said the microblog had become the public’s third most-used source of information.

“China has become much more open and much more transparent. People have a lot of freedom to express themselves and micro-blogging can bring that freedom to the next level,” said Charles Chao, CEO of Sina.com. His company is a leading news portal in China and runs Sina Weibo.

Unlike traditional media channels,micro-blogs allow anyone with an Internet connection to effectively publish whatever they want online. Users can share words,photos and videos with other users and news spreads through the network at lightening speed.

While a micro-blog’s ability to distribute information makes it a useful tool for those following news, the ease of uploading information onto the site also makes it ripe for rumor-mongering.

“Micro-blog misinformation is common and hard to trace. It’s been argued micro-blogs are self-managing, and false misinformation will naturally disappear. But this is a very slow process and not an inevitable or reliable one. Hysterical misinformation often do real damage,” said Wu at the China University of Political Science and Law.

As China’s most popular micro-blog site, Sina Weibo claims it has 50 million registered users, including a large number of celebrities and prominent scholars. These users reportedly write more than 25 million postings a day.

In order to address the misinformation problem, Sina Weibo established a specialized team last November to monitor the accuracy of the information posted by its users.

“With the ever increasing number of micro-blog users and the explosion of available information, it’s dif fi cult for Web users to distinguish postings that are correct from those that are not, so the company decided to set up a group to check postings,” said team leader Tan Chao.

The misinformation-checking team consists of seven members. Many in the group are experienced investigators. “Some are former journalists, some have good foreign language skills, and others have good research skills,” said Tan, who is tasked with moderating Sina Weibo’s avalanche of postings every day.

The team tends to monitor micro-blog postings that make outlandish claims. Tan insists, however, his team is not in charge of censoring postings but rather acts like a moderator, only deleting postings that are proven to be false. Sina Weibo’s policy is to thoroughly investigate suspect micro-blog postings before taking any action.

“We monitor questionable postings that get a lot of reposts over a short period of time,” Tan said.

The team uses a three-step process to track suspect postings. Team members look at how frequently a posting is reposted,then they contact the user who first posted the posting, and fi nally team members do a thorough fact-check to ascertain whether the posting is false.

“We don’t refute a piece of misinformation until we are 100-percent sure it’s wrong and have the evidence to support our judgment,” Tan said. When they encounter controversial topics, the team is obliged to seek the advice of their editor in chief.

Misinformation publishers would be punished, Tan said. The team will deletefalse postings and even close down the accounts of users caught publishing misinformation.

(Left) NEWS IN HAND: A young man browses micro-blogs on his mobile phone on June 3. False information has become a problem for today’s micro-blog users

On June 8, three postings on Sina Weibo said a student in Shaoyang County in central China’s Hunan Province committed suicide on the first day of the national college entrance exam.

The postings said Lu Pin, an 18-year-old student in the No.1 High School in Longhui Township, had arrived 15 minutes late for the exam on June 7 and jumped to his death from the window of his sixth- fl oor dormitory after an exam supervisor prevented him from entering the venue.

After reading the postings and looking at other reports, Tan’s team confirmed the news was a piece of false information. Team members discovered the local police received calls alerting them of a suicide at 8:57 a.m., three minutes before the exam began.It’s clear late arrival could not have been the reason for the suicide.

As a punishment, the investigative team closed the three users’ accounts for one month.

Sina Weibo’s team’s account now has more than 300,000 followers and the team encourages netizens to send in any questionable postings they encounter.

The diligence of the team’s fact checking means it only refutes one or two postings every couple of days, Tan said.The Beijing Morning Postsaid the team had dispelled 129 pieces of misinformation since it was established.

“Misinformation is easily made, but disproving it can be tough,” Tan said. “We have no idea where the next one will come from.”

But Tan admits misinformation appears more often during disasters. For example,he said, after the devastating earthquake and tsunami in Japan in March, many postings asserted, wrongly, China was in imminent danger from radiation release from damaged Japanese power plants, which helped fuel the panic buying of iodized salt. At that time,Tan’s team had to call 10 other Sina.com staff to help deal with misinformation.

Besides Sina Weibo, other major microblogging service providers in China, such as Sohu.com, QQ.com and 163.com, have also established investigative teams and opened official accounts on their sites to release their fi ndings.

Vigilante misinformation hunters

It’s not just micro-blogging service providers that are taking up challenge in dispelling misinformation. In May, a number of civic-minded netizens, including Dou Hanzhang, set up the Anti-misinformation League on Sina Weibo to help other microblog users identify false information.

The group is a collaborative effort that includes scholars, media professionals, lawyers, and university students, many of whom have never met each other. They communicate through instant postings.

“We work voluntarily and we do it because we love refuting misinformation,” said Dou, a former fi nancial commentator at the Xinhua News Agency.

Since its establishment, the Antimisinformation League has refuted more than 150 pieces of misinformation and has already attracted more than 10,000 followers.

AUTHENTIC SOURCE: The Sina Weibo’s investigative team has opened an account to refute misinformation

After a heavy downpour in Beijing on June 23, a micro-blogger posted seven photos on the Internet, showing submerged cars on the streets and water leaking into the Taoranting Subway Station and other scenes of fl ooding.

While the images were reposted by thousands of users, the Anti-misinformation League said the images were fake. For example, photos purportedly showing the Beijing Capital International Airport inundated in several feet of water were found to be actually of an airport in south China’s Hainan Province several years ago.

“We’re the clean freaks of misinformation, and we feel it’s incumbent on us to refute as many misinformation as possible,”Dou said.

“We live in an age of new media, so we cannot use old methods to verify misinformation. We cannot wait for traditional media channels to verify the facts through their administrative departments and then release a formal announcement. We need to fight misinformation while they’re spreading. I think this is the best way to deal with misinformation today,” said a journalist with the Xinhua News Agency known as Dianzizheng in the microblogosphere, who volunteers for Dou’s group.

Compared with Sina Weibo’s investigative team, Dou’s group is quicker to act and judge. “We’re much more fl exible than Sina Weibo’s team, since it wants 100-percent certainty and proof,” Dianzizheng said.

Although the Anti-misinformation League has been increasingly active in the battle against Internet misinformation,Dou said the government should take more responsibility and step in to deny misinformation in the face of major disasters.

“Providing reliable information is supposed to be a government’s duty,” Dou said.

In Dianzizheng’s mind, many misinformation stem from government departments’slow response and vague explanations.

“The clari fi cations made by the government are often late and perfunctory,” he said.“In some cases, people don’t trust of fi cials’efforts to deal with issues involving their own incompetence or mistakes because they fail to act responsibly.”

“The government needs to adopt an open attitude and increase its transparency,”Dianzizheng said.