Solar Cells Based on All-Inorganic Halide Perovskites: Progress and Prospects

, ,

Key Laboratory of Mesoscopic Chemistry of MOE, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing, 210023, P.R. China

(Received 2 November 2017; revised 16 January 2018; accepted 20 January 2018)

Abstract:The emergence of perovskite solar cells (PSCs) based on all-inorganic metal halide (IMH) has generated enormous interest in the photovoltaic research community, and the power conversion efficiency (PCE) has exceeded 13%. Despite its outstanding performance in thermal stability, PSCs based on IMH still face problems such as the lack of a suitable band gap and the inability to generate large areas. In this review, we will summarize the latest progress of PSCs based on IMH.

Key words:perovskite solar cells; all-inorganic metal halide; thermal stability

0 Introduction

Organic-inorganic metal halide (OMH) perovskites drawn extreme attention since their tunable bandgap, large absorption coefficient, long electron-hole diffusion, and high charge carrier mobility[1-11]. After about nine years of development, the power conversion efficiency (PCE) of OMH perovskite has reached 22.7%[12-26]. Despite the high performances, because of unstable organic monovalent cations, the OMH perovskites suffered from poor stability under photo, thermal, and moisture stresses[27-38]. So replacing the organic cations with inorganic monovalent cations in the perovskite structure was put forward because inorganic materials usually exhibit higher stability than organic materials, especially at high temperature.

Further, all-inorganic metal halide (IMH) perovskite without any organic components was proposed and developed rapidly in the past three years, and the PCE has exceeded 13%[46-53]. By adjusting the proportion of halide anions and incorporate other ions, the band gaps of PSCs could be adjusted to an acceptable level. And changes in HTMs and ETMs can further improve PCE and thermal stability. Although it still faces problems such as the inability to produce large areas, it still has excellent business prospects and room for development. Following this line of thought, in this review, we will summarize the latest progress of the solar cells based on IMH perovskites.

Fig.1 The structure and properties of the PSCs based on IMH

1 Preparation of Standard PSCs

There were a variety of PSC architectures that have been studied and the structure of F-doped tin oxide (FTO)/compact TiO2(c-TiO2)/mesoporous TiO2(m-TiO2)/IMH/hole transport material (HTM)/Au exhibited the best performance (Fig.1(b))[47,48]. Moreover, various HTM materials were employed in this structure, in result, poly[bis(4-phenyl)(2,4,6-trimethylphenyl)amine] (PTAA) presented the highest PCE of 5.95% with a large open-circuit voltage of 1.28 eV (Fig.1(c)). And Figs.1(d)—(e) compared the properties, especially the stability between the PSCs based on MAPbBr3and CsPbBr3.

Considering the bandgap and stability, CsPbBr3is the most suitable one as the standard PSCs based on IMH. And as for the preparation of perovskite thin films, they can be fabricated by solution processes or physical deposition methods. A variety of deposition techniques, including spin-coating of precursors in one- or two-step sequential methods, spraying, vapor-assisted deposition, gas-assisted solution process, and dual source thermal evaporation were developed[47,54-56]. Among them, one- or two-step sequential methods are the most commonly used methods. A two-step sequential method involves spin-coating the solution of PbBr2onto the m-TiO2substrate and putting it into the solution of CsBr or spin-coating the solution onto it after being dried[57]. And one-step sequential method involves spin-coating the solution of CsPbBr3onto the m-TiO2substrate directly. Compared with two-step sequential method, the temperature of annealing of one-step sequential method could be lower, which makes it easier for fabrication and application based on a flexible polymer substrate[58]. However, the problem of insolubility of Br-rich perovskite is still unsolved when the one-step spin-coating method is chosen. There are also some studies work on chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method, but there is no outstanding performance[59].

2 Adjustment of Standard PSCs

2.1Thechoiceofhalideanions

The CsPbBr3based PSCs showed excellent stability, however, in terms of the light absorption range, CsPbBr3was not an ideal absorber for PSCs due to its large bandgap (about 2.3 eV). Among CsPbCl3, CsPbBr3and CsPbI3, the best choice should be CsPbI3with the smallest bandgap of about 1.73 eV. However, as mentioned above, CsPbI3in the black cubic perovskite phase is unstable in ambient atmosphere and will rapidly convert to yellow non-perovskite phase[60-62].So combining the good stability of CsPbBr3and the small bandgap of CsPbI3, the halide mixed perovskites of CsPb(I1-xBrx)3were proposed. By adjusting the composition, the CsPbIBr2based PSCs displayed a stabilized PEC of 10.56% with negligible hysteresis with an alike bandgap of 1.9 eV[54-56,58,63,64]. Actually, the bandgap of CsPbIBr2was still large to be used as the absorber materials in PSCs.

Despite CsPbIBr2exhibits smaller bandgap than CsPbBr3, the PCEs of the CsPbIBr2based PSCs are not very high till now, and the stability in the ambient atmosphere is still poor. By varying the stoichiometric ratio of K+, the properties of the Cs1-xKxPbI2Br film can be adjusted. Whenx=0.075, the Cs0.925K0.075PbI2Br film showed a significant increase in absorbance intensity over the entire wavelength and exhibited the maximum and average PCEs of 10.0% and 9.1% in PSCs. Furthermore, the PSCs based on Cs0.925K0.075PbI2Br films displayed much higher stability than those based on CsPbI2Br[65].

Actually, the bandgap of CsPbIBr2was still too large to be used as the absorber materials in PSCs. Another strategy to enhance the stability of CsPbI3is to reduce the size of CsPbI3nanocrystals. It was reported that when the size of CsPbI3nanocrystals was reduced to about 5 nm they will become more stable[52]. And the PSCs based on CsPbI3quantum dots (QDs) exhibited good stability when exposed into the ambient atmosphere for 60 d, whose PCE has reached 10.77% with a perfect open circuit voltageVocof 1.23 V[66].

In conclusion, PSCs based on CsPbI3could have a better band gap but poor stability, and its stability could be increased by adjusting the value ofxin CsPb(I1-xBrx)3, incorporating other cations or reducing the size of CsPbI3nanocrystals.

2.2 The choice of divalent metal cation

In addition to adjusting the proportion of halide anions, it is also a good strategy to incorporate other ions in divalent metal cations. Liang and his co-workers have reported the synthesis of a novel Cs-based inorganic perovskite, CsPb0.9Sn0.1IBr2, through a convenient two-step sequential solution-phase process in ambient air without the need for a glovebox or humidity control, and it exhibits a highVocof 1.26 V and a remarkable PCE up to 11.33%. Moreover, the all-inorganic PSCs show good long-term stability and improved endurance against heat and moisture[67]. And Li demonstrated a series of CsPb1-xSnxIBr2perovskite alloys via one-step anti-solvent method (Fig.2(a)), the CsPb0.75Sn0.25IBr2with homogeneous and densely crystallized morphology shows a remarkable PCE of 11.53% and a highVocof 1.21 V with a much improved phase stability and illumination stability. And Lau reported a low-temperature-processed PSCs, CsPb0.98Sr0.02I2Br, achieved a stabilized efficiency at 10.8%[68]. Furthermore, Liang dropped Mn2+into perovskite CsPbIBr2to compensate their shortcomings in band, and found that the encapsulated CsPb0.995Mn0.005I1.01Br1.99cells exhibit good stability in ambient atmosphere (Fig.2(b)) with the highest PCE of 7.36%.

Fig.2 The performance of the PSCs based on CsPbIBr2, CsPb0.995Mn0.005I1.01Br1.99and a series of CsPb1-xSnxIBr2perovskite

Gao and his colleagues proposed replacing Pb2+with Ag+and Bi3+, and PSCs based on Cs2AgBiBr6exhibits the power conversion efficiency of 2.23% withVoc= 1.01 V, short-circuit currentJsc= 3.19 mA/cm2, file factor FF = 69.2%[75]. And replacing lead cation by Fe2+and Cu2+were also investigated. However, there was almost no successful case.

In conclusion, incorporating other ions in divalent metal cations can effectively reduce the bandgap, improve stability, reduce annealing temperature, improve solubility, and increase PCE. In addition, the PSCs based on lead-free IMH perovskites still have huge research space.

2.3 Adjustment of HTMs and ETMs

Though the all-inorganic PSCs showed a perfect stability and PCE, the organic HTM was too expensive. Jin et al. proposed the design of all-inorganic PSCs[50,51], in which the organic HTMs and noble metal electrodes were completely eliminated, as shown in Fig.3(a). And Figs.3(b)—(e) shows the PCE of PSCs with carbon electrode and its stabilities.

A new kind of ETM compared with a new HTM also comes up this year. ZnO@C-60 bilayer was utilized as the electron-transporting layers that demonstrated a high carrier extraction efficiency and low leakage loss. And the new PSC architectures is FTO/NiOx/CsPbI2Br/ZnO@C-60/Ag. Consequently, it yielded a PCE as high as 13.3% with an open circuit voltageVocof 1.14 V, short-circuit currentJscof 15.2 mA·cm-2, and fill factor FF of 0.77[53].

In summary, ETMs and HTMs using all-inorganic materials not only improve stability, but also significantly reduce cost, making it even closer to industrial production.

3 Conclusions

In summary, we reviewed the recent advances of PSCs based on IMH and a summary of the PSCs based on IMH perovskites. PSCs based on IMH shows a perfect stability and lower cost than PSCs based on OMH. And in order to improve the PCEs and stability, and reduce the band gap and annealing temperature, we can adjust the proportion of halide anions and incorporate other ions. Despite of a lot of efforts on it recently, there is a lot of room for improvement. And there are three directions to improve the performance of the PSCs based on IMH perovskites. Firstly, to enhance the stability when exposed into the ambient atmosphere, which is the biggest enemy for most kinds of perovskites. Then, to reduce the bandgap as much as possible. And to replace lead by other metal more environment-friendly. And when we optimize the structure and condition, we must take the IMH advantages into consideration, including cost and stability. Meanwhile, strengthening the basic theoretical research of IMH perovskites is necessary as well. To date, many experimental results on IMH perovskites have been reported, however, systematic theoretical simulations on them are not enough. In addition, currently produced high-PCE PSCs are all small-area, unable to achieve large-scale industrial production, and there is still a considerable distance from real commercialization.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the National Key R&D Program of China (Nos.2017YFA0208200, 2016YFB 0700600, 2015CB659300), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos.21573108, 51761135104), the Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province (No.BK20150583), the High-Level Entrepreneurial and Innovative Talents Program of Jiangsu Province, and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (No.020514380146).