Golfing At a Heavy Price

By YIN PUMIN

Golfing At a Heavy Price

By YIN PUMIN

Mushrooming golf courses add additional burdens to the worsening water crisis

Golfing is a not a popular sport in Yulin, a coal-mining city sitting in close proximity to the Ordos Desert in northwest China’s Shaanxi Province. But in recent months, a growing number of local residents have begun to pay attention to the pastime, which is said to be guzzling their water resources thirstily.

On August 15,TheBeijing Newsreported two golf courses, covering 267 hectares of land, had been illegally constructed in the desert near Yulin, which has an average annual precipitation of only 400 mm.

The two golf courses—one of them is already in use and the other will open shortly—are estimated to use at least 5 million tons of water a year to maintain their emerald green turf, according to the report.

In order to maintain the resorts’ grass, the operators have dug deep wells to access ground water. The wells, however, put a severe strain on the water supplies that local farmers rely on.

Unaffordable

Spurred by China’s rapid economic growth and soaring living standards, golf, which has long been a pastime for the wealthy, is enjoying an explosion in popularity. A number of golf courses have been built in recent years, even though land use concerns led the government to enact an almost complete ban on golf course development in 2004.

It stipulates that a golf course that plans to use more than 66.67 hectares of farmland must be approved by the State Council, or China’s cabinet, before construction.

Despite severe restrictions, statistics from the Golf Education and Research Center at Beijing Forestry University show the number of golf courses in China has more than tripled since 2004, increasing from 170 to about 600 today. These courses take up a total area of 18,670 hectares.

“Only 10 of the 600 golf courses now operating received approval from the government, which implies that most of China’s golf courses were illegally built,” said Dong Liming, a professor at the College of Urban and Environmental Sciences at Peking University.

“Many unlicensed golf courses were supported by local governments and were constructed under the names of country clubs, sports parks or greenbelts,” Dong said.

There are more than 70 golf courses reportedly operating in and around Beijing.

Some experts say a 40-50 hectare course needs at least 3,000 tons of water every day and a standard 18-hole course normally takes up more than 607 hectares of land.

“The annual water consumption of the courses in Beijing amounts to 40 million tons,” said Su Derong, a professor at Beijing Forestry University.

The same amount of water could supply as many as 400,000 three-member households for a year.

In July, China Central Television (CCTV), a national broadcaster, investigated 10 golf courses and found most were using ground water to irrigate their greens.

At the Beyond Champion Golf Club near the Wenyu River in Beijing’s Changping District, CCTV reporters found the sprinklers working 24 hours a day, but the water wasn’t coming from the river.

A groundskeeper disclosed the course used thousands of tons of ground water per day from wells as deep as 20-30 meters to irrigate the 100-hectare course. Although the course is located near the Wenyu River, the club’s management allegedly said the river was too polluted to use for irrigation.

A manager of another golf course near the Yongding River in southwest Beijing also admitted the course used water from an 80-meter-deep well.

While golf courses are making lavish use of water, the shortage of water has long been a bottleneck for the economic and social development of Beijing. The city’s per-capita water availability stands at just 100 tons, only 10 percent of the international standard per capita, according to the Beijing Water Authority.

Water shortages have forced the city to use water from the adjacent Hebei Province and over-exploit ground water. Beijing’s ground water levels have decreased more than 20 meters in the past 50 years, the authority said.

Golf course construction is not confned to Beijing. In Hebei, a large number of golf courses are tapping the underground water that local villagers rely on for their crops. In some places, it is necessary to drill down more than 100 meters to fnd water.

In one of the most extreme cases, some villagers in Dalian, northeast China’s Liaoning Province, no longer have drinking water on tap because of a nearby golf course.

“Most people rely on ground water. Golf courses lower water levels and this affects residents,” said Ma Jun, Director of the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs, a Beijing-based environmental NGO.

Given the fact 400 of the more than 600 cities in China are suffering from water shortages, the enormous thirst of the country’s new golf courses is simply unsustainable. Once depleted, ground water stocks take centuries to recover.

According to a report in Beijing-basedOriental Weekly, China’s golf courses soak up an average of 1.56 million tons of water every day. But that isn’t the only negative environmental impact of a golf course.

第一步，教師確定作文評改標準，劃分作文評改小組，確定小組作文循環順序，以本組作文水平最高的學生為組長，指導本組作文修改。第二步，將學生作文分為“A”“B”“C”“D”四個等級，以四個等級的評分和評語為引導，將學生作文按循環順序發回修改。第三步，修改完畢后，小組長組織組員對評改情況進行討論，最終上交給老師。

“Golf courses are not just watered but weeded and fertilized. The pesticides used on golf courses pollute the soil, ground water, and even the surface water,” said Hu Lin, a professor at the College of Resources and Environmental Sciences at China Agricultural University.

Studies indicate a 66.67-hectare 18-hole golf course consumes at least 13 tons of fertilizers and pesticides, less than half of which are absorbed by the lawn, leaving tons of fertilizer to fnd its way into reservoirs and rivers.

CCTV reporters found a golf course in Dalian had been discharging contaminated water into a local reservoir, which supplies drinking water to the city’s residents.

Furthermore, scientists said the subsidence and cave-ins that had recently occurred in some cities might also be blamed on the construction of new golf courses in nearby areas. The huge amounts of ground water consumed by these golf courses can cause land to sink.

“Thorough research on golf courses, both existing and under construction, should be done, with harsh punishments, to curb those programs occupying more farmland,” said Yan Jinming, Vice President of the School for Public Administration and Policy at Beijingbased Renmin University of China. “The environmental impacts of each golf course need to be included in this research.”

Profit driven

Local governments seeking profts from land sales are behind China’s recent golf course boom, said industry insiders.

In the frst half of this year, the Ministry of Land and Resources received 34 reports of unlicensed golf course projects, up 31 percent year on year, according to a statement released by the ministry on July 29.

The problem of unlicensed golf courses has expanded from coastal areas to the central and western regions of the country. Illegal course construction has been reported in 17 provinces, municipalities and autonomous regions.

Since 2009, the government of Tengchong County in southwest China’s Yunnan Province has approved more than a dozen golf courses without consent of land authorities. Local offcials said the projects were part of their efforts to attract investment and boost tourism.

Feng Ke, Director of the Real Estate Finance Research Center at Peking University, said most of the unlicensed golf courses were developed under the guise of“eco-tourism projects” or “property development.”

In Beijing, most golf courses are located near top-end villas and resorts. According to Feng, only a few of them were built in compliance with current policies.

At the Qinghewan Golf Course, a sprawling 36-hole golf complex within sight of the National Stadium near Beijing’s Fourth Ring Road, a lifetime membership costs nearly 1 million yuan ($156,400). However, the course has yet to get approval from the municipal government, according to the Beijing Municipal Bureau of Land and Resources.

Chen Guoqiang, Vice Chairman of the China Real Estate Society, said some local governments had turned a blind eye to irregularities in land development examination and approval procedures or are even involved in the illegal projects themselves.

“They have invited developers to open new golf courses, claiming they are good for economic development, boosting employment and improving the investment environment,” he said.

Chen said several officials have been sacked or penalized for lax supervision over golf course development, but he acknowledged that enforcement of relevant regulations needed to be further intensifed.

“The offcials know about every underthe-counter deal. Supervision should be tightened,” he said.

Professor Su at the Beijing Forestry University said the ban currently in force was impractical. He suggested a clear system with straightforward criteria be established to evaluate applications and issue certifcates.

Yan from the Renmin University of China said authorities should consider easing the restrictions on golf course construction, and in the meantime adopt stricter screening measures to make sure approvals are issued with full consideration of environmental protection and economic sustainability.

“In the long term, golfing should be made more affordable to the broader public in China, instead of being a privilege for the rich,” he said.

On July 20, the State Council ordered checks on all golf courses to prevent illegal land use and to prevent the loss of farmland.

On August 17, the National Development and Reform Commission posted a notice on its website, saying local governments are barred from approving new golf courses or allowing the construction of approved ones before the Central Government releases further regulations on the development of the sector.

According to the notice, a campaign is underway to regulate existing golf courses. And since April, golf course operators have been required to vacate any farmland and forestland they illegally occupy.

considerable revenues from land sales, and the development of high-end facilities such as golf courses pushed up property prices in surrounding areas.