Easing Housing Woes

By LI LI

Easing Housing Woes

By LI LI

HOUSING FOR CONSTRUCTORS:A low-cost apartment community for migrant workers nears completion in Fuzhou,Fujian Province,in August

A new housing law brings the hope of decent housing for everyone

Legions of urban residents now priced out of China’s booming housing market may soon get relief under a new law working its way through China’s legislative system.

Xinhua News Agency reported on November 8 the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development submitted a draft Basic Housing Security Law to the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress (NPC). The NPC is now soliciting opinions from other governmental units. The draft law sets standards for low-income housing construction and management; speci fi es applicant requirements; and deals with related issues such as rent subsidies for low-income earners; economic incentives and taxation;and housing guarantees for farmers.

The law is intended to rectify problems caused by the commercialization of China’s real estate sector. Over the past 12 years,market reforms in the industry have generated jaw-dropping pro fi ts and brought huge revenues to local governments through land sales. However, astronomical prices have meant many people are unable to own their own apartments and are often reduced to living in crowded, overpriced housing.

A new term has even sprung up to describe such people “ant tribes.” These people, often low-income college graduates,frequently live in tiny rooms in overstuffed apartments subdivided to fi t 10 or 20 people,instead of three or four as originally intended.They should have been entitled to low-priced government housing for rent if there was suffi cient supply of this kind of housing.

Twelve years ago, the government attempted to provide for low- and middleincome earners when it commercialized the housing market. However, State Council directives and local implementing regulations were not satisfactorily implemented.

An editorial published on the website of Shanghai-basedXinmin Evening Newssaid, with the new law under consideration,China’s housing system is returning in some ways to its starting point 12 years ago. Under the earlier system, housing was distributed to people at below-market prices, usually through their place of employment. Although the new law may seem in some ways like a return to the past, the editorial said it is actually a symbol of progress since market tools and social welfare policies will be combined to guarantee citizens’ right to housing.

The much-anticipated new law is expected to ensure the construction of affordable and low-rent housing. In recent years, the booming real estate market created disincentives for building less pro fi table housing.

Gao Fengtao, Vice Director of the Legislative Affairs Office of the State Council, said in March that the law is expected to be implemented in 2011.

Affordable housing problems

While more and more people have found jobs in big cities as China’s urbanization has accelerated, the amount of affordable housing has not kept up due to a lack of funds and land.

Statistics released by the NPC in October showed that the Central Government had already spent its annual budget for the construction of affordable housing, 79.2 billion yuan ($11.8 billion), by the end of August.At the same time, local governments, which should shoulder part of the cost, said they faced dif fi culty in raising money for housing.According to the NPC report, only 23.6 percent of the housing funds required from local authorities in 2009 had been allocated in the fi rst eight months of that year.

Another problem is that local authorities are reluctant to spare land for low-income housing projects since they yield low pro fi ts.Tao Yan, a professor at Renmin University of China, said local governments, whose rev-enue relies heavily on the land sales, have no motivation to provide land for building lowincome housing.

“When one plot of land is used for the construction of affordable and low-priced housing, the price for nearby plots of land immediately falls in auctions. It is impossible for governments to harm their own interests,”Tao toldChina Business News. Tao said that the fundamental solution is to change government’s position as the sole land supplier.

Shen Weixing of Tsinghua University’s School of Law toldChina Business Newsthat funds for building affordable housing should be mainly provided by local governments while private capital should be encouraged to participate too. Shen also said of fi cials of local governments should be evaluated on their efforts to build low-priced housing and should be held accountable if they fail to meet their targets.

In October, the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development said it will conduct an inspection of affordable housing construction nationwide in cooperation with other government departments. Local government leaders who are in charge of affordable housing construction will be directly criticized if the projects in their cities or provinces are proceeding too slowly.

Local government of fi cials will be evaluated. Those in areas where low-priced housing goals are not being met will be criticized in written notices. On the other hand, areas that have surpassed their low-priced housing goals will be rewarded by the Central Government.

Current measures

The much-anticipated new law is expected to ensure the construction of affordable and low-rent housing.In recent years, the booming real estate market created disincentives for building less profitable housing

In advance of a comprehensive law,many locales have introduced measures to curb real estate speculation, a key factor driving up housing prices. For example, many cities restrict residents to buying only one or two apartments. Cities have also tightened down-payment requirements and adjusted mortgage interest rates.

ECSTASY OF WINNING: Liang Yan, from Hefei, Anhui Province,hugs her son after her family won the chance to purchase a low-cost apartment in December 2009

Even when low-priced housing projects have been built, however, bene fi ts have not always fl owed to their intended low-income recipients. For example, a low-priced housing lottery scam was exposed last June in Wuhan, the capital of Hubei Province. More than 5,000 people applied for 124 housing units. However, individuals involved in the lottery allegedly took nearly 1 million yuan($149,000) in bribes and arranged for six consecutive numbers to win.

In a more recent scandal, a publicized list of applicants for low-priced housing in Shenzhen, who had already received firststage approval, included people who already owned luxury homes and couples who were both civil servants.

China Business Newsalso reported in November that Guo Yunchong, Vice Minister of Housing and Urban-Rural Development, admitted that some low-priced housing had been distributed to civil servants as part of their employment bene fi ts.

Taking Beijing as an example, according to a November 15 story bySouthern Metropolis News, more than 70 percent of land used for residential projects in Beijing between 2005 and 2009 quali fi ed for government fi nancial incentives. However, only about 7 percent of this housing was sold publicly. The report said the remaining housing was mainly sold by government ministries to their employees at much lower than market prices.

Shen from Tsinghua University, who participated in drafting the new law, said the new low-priced housing generated by the law should mainly be low-rent housing. Insuring that tenants don’t own the housing should prevent speculation. Shen also suggested joint ownership of affordable housing between purchasers and local governments. He also proposed expanding eligibility for lowpriced housing to migrant workers living in cities.