Football Gets a Red Card

By LI XIAO

Football Gets a Red Card

By LI XIAO

RISE AND FALL: Wei Di (above) takes over as Director of the Soccer Administrative Center of the General Administration of Sport after an anti-corruption campaign sunk former soccer officials including Nan Yong, Yang Yimin, Xie Yalong, Li Dongsheng and Wei Shaohui (bottom, left to right)

Referees blow the whistle on their collaborations with officials in match-fixing scandals

China’s trouble-plagued top soccer league,the Chinese Football Association Super League (CSL), kicked off its 2011 season on April 2 without a sponsor or a national TV deal. Days before the new season, three former league referees, who are awaiting trial,revealed the extent of match-fixing scandals that have led to the punishment of clubs, officials, coaches and former players.

‘Golden whistle’ down

Three referees, including veteran “golden whistle” Lu Jun, have been arrested on charges of accepting bribes from soccer clubs, Law Online, a China Central Television (CCTV)program, said on March 30.

The program disclosed details of their involvement in corruption cases.

Lu, 51, officiated in two World Cup matches, several Asian Football Confederation tournaments and more than 200 domestic league matches before retiring in 2005. He was also honored as Referee of the Year twice by the Asian Football Confederation—in 1999 and 2004.

Lu confessed he had been asked by Zhang Jianqiang, his alumni at Beijing Sport University and a former official of the Chinese Football Association (CFA), to referee in Shanghai Shenhua’s favor in its derby rivalry against Shanghai International on November 9, 2003. The two teams were both title hopefuls in that season of the CSL.

Lu manipulated the match by treating Shenhua players less strictly as Shenhua outplayed International in a 4-1 triumph and finally managed to win the year’s league championship.

“I’m the middleman between the Shenhua club and Lu,” said Zhang, revealing he was given commissions worth 700,000 yuan ($106,774). He and Lu each received 350,000 yuan ($53,387) afterward.

“I was sort of scared at that time because China had been cracking down on match fi xing, but bribery of referees before matches was rife then,” said Lu.

“I love the job of being a football referee and I paid a lot for it. But devotion doesn’t mean indulgence in crime and it was greed which made me the person I am today,” he said.

Other corrupt referees appearing in the CCTV program were Zhou Weixin and Huang Junjie.

“I worked quite a few of these kinds of games that were rigged from the top,” theBeijing Youth Dailyquoted Huang as saying.

“For many years, I felt guilty to my parents, guilty to the football fans,” said Huang,who was nominated for the Referee of the Year award for the 2009 CSL season.

Cui Weidong, an of fi cial in charge of the investigation into the corruption in soccer,said that bribing referees has been a common practice for years. “Football clubs gave bribes to referees through a variety of means.On most occasions, they gave cash directly and the amounts varied according to the importance of the match involved,” he said.

Chronic problem

Match-fixing allegations are more a recurring illness rather than an accidental flu for China’s soccer, and many other problems have bothered it for more than a decade.

From the starting whistle of Lu when the Chengdu and Liaoning clubs played each other in the 1994 season, China’s soccer stepped into a new era of professionalism. In its fi rst years, the problem of what is termed“black whistle” referees was not severe as referees received local souvenirs at most.

Starting in 1997, the amounts involved in bribery soared rapidly. A former CFA of fi cial said referee’s commissions for important matches had reached 100,000 yuan ($15,296).

Allegations of corruption in soccer spread widely before an anti-corruption campaign initiated by Zhejiang Lucheng Club Manager Song Weiping in 2002, and a roster was submitted on nine referees who were alleged to have taken bribes from the club.

Although the campaign won public support, the CFA adopted a policy of “you own up and we’ll let bygones be bygones” in handling the allegations.

Finally, referee Gong Jianping, who publicly pleaded guilty, was sentenced to 10 years behind bars for taking 370,000 yuan($56,595) in bribes as a civil servant. He died of pneumonia in 2004. Besides Gong, only 17 linesmen were punished.

The situation went down the drain as more referees made dubious decisions at the instigation of club managers and CFA off i cials. The CSL ran the 2005 season without a title sponsorship because of numerous scandals such as match- fi xing, the bribing of referees and gambling.

The CFA announced it was joining the Ministry of Public Security to fight against the scandals and a new initiative was taken to crack down on illegal activities in November 2009.

The long-time investigation implicated scores of leading club and CFA of fi cials and referees. Among them were Nan Yong and Yang Yimin, both former Vice Chairmen of the CFA who were arrested for alleged match fixing and bribery in January 2010.Xie Yalong, another former Vice Chairman of the CFA, was arrested for bribery last September.

The Guangzhou and Chengdu clubs in the CSL were relegated and Qingdao Hailifeng Club in the second division was kicked out due to involvement in match- fi xing scandals.

Multi-role playing

Why is the CSL entangled to such a large degree in match-fixing scandals?Despite deafening appeals for fair play from fans, China’s soccer, lacking self-discipline and the will to reform itself, still acted like an untamed animal.

Ma Dexing, a journalist with sports newspaperTitan Weekly, said, “These years,people in sports circles are always thinking about how to be responsible to higher authorities rather than to the market or fans.”

Chen Peide, former Director of Zhejiang Provincial Sport Bureau, said, “When the corruption fi rst occurred, no one disapproved of it and it gradually turned into common practice, straying further and further from the right path. It is the reason why China’s soccer went bad.”

Wang Dazhao, a senior reporter withPeople’s Daily, said the “fatal weakness” of China’s soccer was a lack of professionalism in the sport.

“We have only a super fi cial knowledge about soccer,” said Wang. “We take it as just a contest producing a winner and the loser,but in other countries it’s deemed not only a sport but also a kind of culture. When soccer was connected to big money and everyone wanted to pro fi t from it, it went wrong from the very beginning.”

DISGRACED:Huang Junjie, a former international referee, admits he made unfair calls in China’s top soccer league matches in return for bribes from clubs

The root of the problem issues from a“one of fi ce, three signs” situation. The CFA also functions as the Soccer Administrative Center of the General Administration of Sport and runs the CSL Co. that is responsible for managing sponsorships and the business affairs of the league. The same body acts concurrently as supervisor, administrator and operator, resulting in vulnerability to corruption.

Wei Di, Director of the Soccer Administrative Center of the General Administration of Sport, said a new mechanism has been adopted which means no CFA leader, including himself, can decide the assigning of referees—and 20 percent of the referees working in the 2011 CSL season are new.

Efforts have been intensi fi ed to separate the operations of the CSL from the CFA, and the latter will now only serve as the governing body of the sport.